Blog Layout

Feeling Sheepish - Sheepshead Fishing in Crystal River

Nick Warrington • February 5, 2025

For Florida anglers, sheepshead are a wintertime staple. These black and white fish are prized for their table fare as well as their challenge to hook. As the seasons change and the water and air temperatures drop, many of the classic game fish species become harder to target. Sheepshead offer anglers an opportunity to catch a cooler full of delicious fish and have a blast while doing it. Before we dive too far into fishing for sheepshead in Crystal River, we should go over what a sheepshead is. 

The Sheepshead

Depending on where in the country you live, sheepshead is a name for very different fish. These aren't the pacific red and blackfish, nor the freshwater drum of the Midwest. The sheepshead we are fishing for is Archosargus probatocephalus, the black and white barred fish known for its human-like teeth. 


Yep, teeth. The sheepshead feeds primarily on crustaceans and mollusks, where they put their molars and incisors to work crushing shells of their food. Their favorite foods coincide with rock piles, docks, and bridges where barnacles, crabs, and small fish are common. Sheepshead aren't large fish; the Florida state record is 15lb 2oz, with most fish between 3 and 8 pounds. Their wariness and sharp eyesight require anglers to use downsized gear, making fighting these relatively small fish an absolute blast for anglers of any age.

When to Catch Sheepshead?

Sheepshead fishing is available year-round; however, with so many other species available for the warmer water months, the sheepshead tends to be overlooked. January to March are ideal months to try fishing for sheepshead as the cold water keeps them congregated around their food sources; March and April are the spawning months, so the fish tend to congregate in even greater numbers for those months. Unlike other species, sheepshead are social fish, so when you catch one, there are likely a few more to pull out of the same spot.

Where to Catch Sheepshead?

The most typical fishing advice for sheepshead is to target bridge pilings with loads of barnacles. Fishing Crystal River for sheepshead is different. Unlike most of the state, Crystal river doesn't have many saltwater bridges and docks to target sheepshead from. Instead of anchoring below a bridge and fishing the pilings, we head 10-20 miles offshore to the rock piles where sheepshead spend most of their time. These rockpiles are less affected by tides and daily temperature swings, so there is a good likelihood that the fishing trip will turn into a catching trip.

  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button

What is a Catching Trip?

Many anglers have heard the phrase, "It's called fishing, not catching," and while no one can guarantee a fish, these rockpile excursions are about the closest you can come. Not only are loads of sheepshead schooled up to feed and spawn, but many other species are swimming around the same piles too. Anglers can catch mangrove snapper, grunts, and even hogfish while dropping shrimp. When baits are dropped with frequency, and more fish begin to notice the activity, fishing can become an all-out frenzy. Multiple hookups are expected, with anglers dipping and ducking under each other with a rod doubled over from an excited fish. Snappers, grunts, and sheepshead all have relatively high bag limits, allowing a party of anglers to catch more than enough fish for a whole block party. Naturally, the show star is the sheepshead, and with a bag limit of 8 fish per angler, there are still more than enough tasty filets to go around.


In conclusion, the sheepshead is a phenomenal fish to target in the winter. Their food quality and fight are unmatched. Pairing those attributes with the healthy bag limits anglers can take, and it's no wonder they are so popular for anglers to target. With the lack of bridges and seawalls, Crystal River may not have the textbook locations for sheepshead; far too many anglers think of redfish and seatrout fishing instead. The truth is Crystal River has some of the best locations to target sheepshead on the gulf coast. With offshore rockpiles that can give constant action and the possibility of a mixed bag, it's Florida's best-kept secret. For anglers looking to chase away the wintertime doldrums and bring home a cooler of filets for the fryer or grill, a sheepshead trip is exactly what's needed. Give us a call or email us to book your next sheepshead trip with High Octane Fishing.

Check out some of our other blog posts:

By Capt. Nick Warrington January 22, 2025
There are few fish in Florida that attract as much attention as the Cobia. A migratory nearshore fish, the Cobia is prized for its combination of fight and table fare. How these fish are targeted in Florida makes them even more attractive to anglers who, at times, will custom design their vessels to make targeting them easier. This article will cover the ins and outs of cobia fishing, such as the state tackle record, fishing techniques, peak seasons, and even a recipe for preparing your catch.
By Capt. Nick Warrington January 20, 2025
Florida is an angler's paradise, offering some of the best fishing experiences in the world. Whether you’re a seasoned deep-sea enthusiast, a casual fisher, or planning a family adventure, Florida’s waters are brimming with opportunities to create unforgettable memories. This guide walks you through everything you need to know about booking a fishing charter in 2025—from exploring top destinations to finding the perfect charter for your needs.
By Capt. Nick Warrington January 9, 2025
A New Year Brings New Fishing Opportunities
Three men are standing on a boat holding fish.
By Capt. Nick Warrington January 8, 2025
Looking for a unique way to connect with your team, clients, or family? A group fishing trip in Crystal River, Florida, is an unforgettable experience that combines fun, camaraderie, and relaxation in a beautiful setting. Whether you’re planning a corporate team outing, client appreciation event, or a family reunion, fishing the Nature Coast of Florida offers a perfect balance of adventure and bonding.
Crystal River Florida Scallops
By Capt. Nick Warrington January 3, 2025
Crystal River, Florida, a hidden gem nestled along the Gulf Coast, is not only known for its breathtaking natural beauty and picturesque landscapes but also for a unique and thrilling summer activity: scalloping. This delightful underwater adventure combines exploration, relaxation, and a dash of adrenaline, making it a must-try experience for locals and visitors alike. In this article, we'll dive into the current scalloping season, catch limits, and techniques.
By Capt. Nick Warrington November 20, 2024
Past couple of months have been a whirlwind for us here in Crystal River, Florida, between trying to make the most of our extelmly short grouper season and getting back to back hurricanes. Let's take a look at what's been happening on the water and what you can expect as we move forward.
Show More

Questions? SEND US A MESSAGE

Contact Us

Share by: